Birmingham Businesses 'Have Nothing to Fear' from Proposed Liquor License Change

A tentative plan from City Manager Bob Bruner would require all new businesses with a liquor license to obtain a special permit from the city.

As the city moves forward on plans to change the way Birmingham's liquor licenses are regulated, City Manager Bob Bruner has a message for existing businesses: you have nothing to fear.

"I don't think the existing licensees have as much to fear as much as they think they do," said Bruner at the July 25 planning board meeting.

During last week's meeting, the planning board held a study session on a tentative plan to amend the city's zoning code so that any business looking to sell on-premise alcohol would only be permitted with a Special Land Use Permit (SLUP).

, who said new state rules have stripped local municipalities of their power to regulate liquor license transfers — making it even harder to regulate those licenses and the businesses who own them.

According to the new rules, approved by the Michigan Liquor Control Commission (MLCC) and effective July 1, businesses do not have to receive local approval to transfer a liquor license. Businesses only need approval from the MLCC.

Not only does this mean Birmingham's existing licenses can now be transferred at will, but licenses from other cities can also be transferred in — and city officials wouldn't know anything about it.

"We could literally have 500 liquor licenses in town," said city attorney Tim Currier.

Current businsses would need special permit with name change, change of owners

To solve this problem, Bruner is proposing that new businesses with liquor licenses receive SLUPs, which requires them to come before the Birmingham City Commission for final approval.

In addition, a SLUP would also be required should any business — new or existing — wish to change its name or owners.

While several planning board members said they were in favor of such a policy change — particularly in light of several public safety incidents earlier this spring — many raised concerns with how the plan could impact existing businesses.

Bruner said he hasn't yet met with business owners though he's promised to meet with them before a public hearing on the issue in front of the city commission on Aug. 13.

"The only part of this that makes me a little sketchy ... (is) I wonder whether a change in the name or a simple sign permit is excessive (for a SLUP)," said Scott Clein, a planning board member.

Bruner said the ultimate end-goal is to have every business with a liquor license under a SLUP. However, should an existing business need to go before the city commission, Bruner said they shouldn't have too many problems.

"I happen to think the existing establishments are going to get a pretty fair shake with this city commission," he said.

According to Planning Director Jana Ecker, if a business were looking to simply replace their sign because of regular wear-and-tear, they would not be required to obtain a SLUP under the new plan. Businesses wouldn't need SLUPs if they were doing simple renovations, either.

However, any changes to a business's site plans — such as if a restaurant wanted to add outdoor dining — would require a SLUP application.

"We need to be mindful and respectful of the investment (existing businesses) have made in our community," said planning board member Gillian Lazar. "I somehow feel that we musn't look like it's us versus them. We're looking more to the future and what may come in, and not punishing those who are already here."

Bruner believes residents will support plan

Bruner said he believes Birmingham's residents will back this plan, particularly considering the feedback he received after . The Birmingham City Commission will hold a public hearing on revoking South's liquor license on Aug. 13.

"The community was saying good riddance and God speed to the city who wants to put stricter control on liquor licenses," Bruner said. "I think that's where we're at as a community."

Resident Dorothy Conrad said she believes many of Birmingham's current liquor license holders are upset over the many public safety incidents downtown.

"I think you would find support on the part of them," she said. "It is important that we get a handle on this. It's good for the existing licensees. It doesn't harm them."

The planning board will discuss the issue again next Wednesday during a public hearing. The following Monday, on Aug. 13, the Birmingham City Commission will hold its own public hearing on the issue.

Bruner admitted the process is moving quick. "We're trying to close this window as quickly as we can," he said.

Debbie Thomas August 02, 2012 at 01:27 PM
Wonderful! This city does not want the kind of businesses which can only exist by being a magnet for drunken riffraff. We want controls on these places, all of them!
R Jeppostol August 02, 2012 at 09:56 PM
Because of the BPD's proven lack of effectiveness in handling/stifling post-last-call drunken mischief--unlike their counterparts in say Royal Oak, for example--and the consequent glaring inadequacy in protection that results, I think the city has no choice but to implement special provisions/measures such as these. Special Land Use Permits will act as the necessary crutches/training-wheels for the BPD while they learn to better handle post-last-call shenanigans. Given the glaringly more than adequate funding they receive, this is a disappointing albeit ultimately necessary next step to stanch the bleeding, so to speak, from an injured city.
Debbie Thomas August 03, 2012 at 01:41 AM
What you call drunken mischief and shenanigans is probably what most city residents would call distasteful and criminal behavior. Why should criminals like this be let loose on city residents at any time?
R Jeppostol August 03, 2012 at 03:19 AM
@Debbie Thomas, You should ask the BPD not me. For the most part, I agree with you.
Greg Thrasher August 16, 2012 at 01:24 PM
This is overkill and only creates more barriers to economic growth in Birmingham. The BPD are not responsible for the criminal acts of others.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »